Little Anthony & The Imperials, We Are…, End 303, 1959
Not to sound like a broken record, but I always buy any reasonably priced 50s record. Not just because I usually get one home and find a pleasant surprise when I look it up in my trusty Goldmine Record Album Price Guide, but also because they are really fun to listen to. This record was a little bit of both.
There were two price tags on this record. While I knew this record would be valuable, the $100 price tag meant I would never get to know what it sounded like. Then I noticed the second price tag. At $5, I didn’t have to think twice about buying it. But what price tag was right? The clerk charged me $5, and I didn’t question him, so I raced home with it to look it up. It turns out that this little $5 record would also be a value at $100. Goldmine values We Are The Imperials at $250 for a good copy.
Sure, there is some hiss, but the record is a very good copy. The hit, Tears On My Pillow lead it off, but the whole album is filled with that classic New York Doo-Wop sound. Eagle-Eyed Neil Sedaka fans will notice The Diary on here. Sedaka was thrilled to present his best song to The Imperials for this record as a follow up to Tears…, but it didn’t chart. The failure of it was a shock to him to the point where he recorded it himself. It was his first single as an artist, and a pretty good sized hit. But trivia aside, I found a real gem $245 under value!
Cost: $5, $37 Remaining