May 26, 2017 Little Anthony, Big Value

IMG_1285

Little Anthony & The Imperials, We Are…, End 303, 1959

Not to sound like a broken record, but I always buy any reasonably priced 50s record.  Not just because I usually get one home and find a pleasant surprise when I look it up in my trusty Goldmine Record Album Price Guide, but also because they are really fun to listen to.  This record was a little bit of both.

IMG_1286

There were two price tags on this record.  While I knew this record would be valuable, the $100 price tag meant I would never get to know what it sounded like.  Then I noticed the second price tag.  At $5, I didn’t have to think twice about buying it.  But what price tag was right?  The clerk charged me $5, and I didn’t question him, so I raced home with it to look it up.  It turns out that this little $5 record would also be a value at $100.  Goldmine values We Are The Imperials at $250 for a good copy.

IMG_1287

Sure, there is some hiss, but the record is a very good copy.  The hit, Tears On My Pillow lead it off, but the whole album is filled with that classic New York Doo-Wop sound.  Eagle-Eyed Neil Sedaka fans will notice The Diary on here.  Sedaka was thrilled to present his best song to The Imperials for this record as a follow up to Tears…, but it didn’t chart.  The failure of it was a shock to him to the point where he recorded it himself.  It was his first single as an artist, and a pretty good sized hit.  But trivia aside, I found a real gem $245 under value!

Today’s Summary:
Cost: $5, $37 Remaining

May 20, 2017 I Wonder How (I Got So Lucky)

IMG_1211

Dion & The Belmonts, Presenting…, Laurie LLP-1002, 1959

It always seems to be a good idea to buy any playable 50s album that you find.  To find this record at the price I paid, it also takes a seller who doesn’t know what they are doing.  Sure, I know about Dion & The Belmonts, and this would appear to be their first album.  Remembering that albums of the era were usually just collections of a group’s singles, it didn’t surprise me to find virtually every Dion & The Belmonts’ song I knew on it.  I still splurged a little bit, but I had no idea how rare this record was until I got home to research it.

IMG_1212.jpg

This 1959 release is the original Laurie issue (LLP-1002), which was re-released in 1960 after the Top 10 success of Where Or When as LLP-2002.  A near copy of this record is valued at $250 in my Goldmine price guide.  While there may not a near mint copy of the record out there after 58 years, I feel really good about finding this copy at $7.  Apparently, the 1960 re-issue sold better (Where Or When turned out to be the group’s biggest hit), but it’s still rare enough to be valued at $150.

IMG_1213

Still, I have a feeling that a larger or more diligent record seller would realize the rarity of a record like this and price it out of range for my budget.  I found it at a store that specializes in alternative and classic rock records.  It’s quite possible that this record got dropped off there by someone looking to sell their grandparents records and was quickly graded by an overwhelmed clerk who doesn’t know the difference between Dion and Celine Dion.  Which is a-ok with me!

Today’s Summary:
Cost: $7, $70 Remaining